You’ve been dating a man for a while, and you finally meet his family for the first time. His sister introduces you to her husband, and you realize you hooked up with him in the past.

So do you pull your boyfriend aside and tell him? Or do you keep it a secret?

In this case, the brother-in-law begged our listener to keep it a secret. Should she?

The Update

Did she tell her boyfriend over the weekend? Here’s the update…